An Employee Shared a Coworker's Salary: Can I Discipline Them?

An employee found out what a coworker makes: maybe they saw a document, maybe someone told them, and they shared that information.  Now there’s drama.  Maybe resentment.  And you want to discipline the person who started it.

Before you do, you need to understand one of the most commonly violated employment law protections in small businesses: the right to discuss wages.

The NLRA Protects Wage Discussions

The National Labor Relations Act gives employees the right to engage in “concerted activity” for the purpose of collective bargaining or mutual aid and protection.  Courts and the NLRB have consistently interpreted this to include discussing wages, salaries, benefits, and working conditions with coworkers.

This protection applies to virtually all private sector employees in the United States, whether or not they are unionized, whether or not they work for a large or small company, and regardless of what your company policy says.

Critical Point: A company policy that prohibits employees from discussing their wages with coworkers is unenforceable under the NLRA.  If you have such a policy in your handbook or employment agreement, it is void.  Enforcing it by disciplining an employee for discussing wages is an unfair labor practice that can be reported to the NLRB.

What You Generally Cannot Do

•       Discipline an employee for telling a coworker their own salary

•       Discipline an employee for asking a coworker what they make

•       Discipline an employee for discussing pay disparities with coworkers

•       Enforce a policy that prohibits wage discussions

•       Threaten or retaliate against employees for engaging in wage discussions

What You Potentially Can Do

There is a narrow category of employees who may be excluded from NLRA protections: supervisors, managers, and certain confidential employees who have access to wage information as part of their job duties.  If a payroll administrator or HR employee shares confidential compensation data they accessed in their professional capacity, the analysis is different.

But for a rank-and-file employee who shared their own salary or a salary they happened to learn, the NLRA protection almost certainly applies, and discipline is an unfair labor practice.

The Real Problem to Address

If salary information being shared is causing conflict, the underlying issue is usually pay equity, not the conversation that revealed it.  Employees who discover significant, unexplained pay disparities between themselves and colleagues in similar roles become disengaged and often leave.  The revelation is uncomfortable precisely because it surfaces something real. For more on the policies that help small businesses avoid preventable workplace conflict, see HR Policies Every Small Business Needs.

The more productive response is to evaluate whether your compensation practices are equitable and whether you can explain pay differences based on legitimate, documented factors: experience, performance, tenure, skills.  If you can, be prepared to have that conversation.  If you cannot, the problem is the pay structure, not the employee who talked about it.

Fix Your Policies

If your employee handbook, employment agreement, or any policy document contains language prohibiting employees from discussing wages or salaries, remove it. This language is unenforceable and its presence signals to employees and regulators that you are trying to prevent them from exercising protected rights. For a full review of what your handbook should and should not include, see What Should Be in an Employee Handbook.

Your confidentiality policy should be narrowly drawn, protecting genuinely proprietary business information like trade secrets, client lists, and financial data, and should explicitly carve out employees’ rights to discuss their own wages and working conditions.

Get a Social Media Policy Template

Our Social Media Policy includes properly written NLRA carve-out language protecting your confidential business information without overreaching into employees’ protected rights to discuss wages and working conditions.

→  Social Media Policy Template — $35 | pragmatichrgroup.com

Editable Word document + PDF.  Instant download.  Created by a SHRM-SCP certified HR professional.

Questions about this or other HR topics? Visit pragmatichrgroup.com for more resources.