What to Do When an Employee Requests Too Much Time Off
Time off requests become a management issue when they are excessive relative to your policy, when they are creating operational problems, or when the pattern suggests the employee is using PTO in ways that conflict with legitimate business needs. Here is how to address it correctly.
First: Define What 'Too Much' Actually Means
Before addressing the issue, get specific. Is the employee requesting more time off than your PTO policy allows? Or are they within their accrued balance but the timing and frequency are creating problems? These are different situations requiring different responses.
'Too much' is not an enforceable standard. 'You have exhausted your accrued PTO balance' or 'you have had four unplanned absences in the last six weeks, which exceeds the threshold defined in our attendance policy' are enforceable standards. Without a written PTO and attendance policy that defines expectations and thresholds, you have no objective basis for the conversation.
Check Whether Legal Protections Apply
Before addressing any time off concern, determine whether the absences or requests might be legally protected:
FMLA: if the employee has a serious health condition or is caring for a qualifying family member, absences may be FMLA-protected regardless of how many there have been
ADA: if the time off is related to a disability, a reasonable accommodation may be required
State leave laws: many states have paid sick leave laws that protect absences for illness or family care
Pregnancy: several federal and state laws protect leave related to pregnancy and childbirth
If any of these apply, the attendance conversation changes significantly. Consult with HR or legal counsel before proceeding, as this can get complicated very quickly.
The Conversation
If the time off is not legally protected and exceeds your policy, the conversation is direct and policy-based:
'I want to talk about your time off over the past [period]. You have [specific number] of absences or requests, which [exceeds your accrued balance / exceeds the attendance thresholds in our policy]. Going forward, I need you to [specific expectation]. I want to understand if there is something going on that I should be aware of.'
Give the employee the opportunity to share context before you make any decisions. There may be a situation that qualifies for a leave accommodation you did not know about.
After the Conversation
Document the conversation with the specific data, the expectation communicated, and the employee's response. If there is a protected leave situation that emerged, initiate the appropriate leave process. If there is not, apply your attendance policy consistently and follow the progressive discipline process if the pattern continues.
Policy First!
If this situation has exposed that you do not have a written PTO and attendance policy, now is the time to create one. Trying to address attendance issues without a written policy is like enforcing a speed limit that is not posted. You need the standard in writing before you can hold anyone to it.
Questions about this or other HR topics? Visit pragmatichrgroup.com for more resources.
