Employee Asked for a Religious Accommodation: What Am I Required to Do?
An employee asked not to work on their Sabbath. Or they requested permission to wear a head covering. Or they asked to be excused from a company event that conflicts with their religious observance. What are you legally required to do?
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act requires employers with 15 or more employees to provide reasonable religious accommodations to employees unless doing so would cause an undue hardship on the business.
The Interactive Process
When an employee requests a religious accommodation, your first obligation is to engage in a good-faith interactive process. This means having a genuine conversation about the request, understanding what the religious need is, and exploring whether and how it can be accommodated.
You are not required to grant every accommodation request. You are, however, required to seriously consider it and engage with the employee in finding a workable solution. For a broader look at the policies that support legally compliant employment practices, see HR Policies Every Small Business Needs.
What Counts as a Religious Belief
The definition of religion under Title VII is broad. It includes not just traditional organized religions but also sincerely held religious, ethical, or moral beliefs that are religious in nature. You generally cannot probe deeply into whether an employee’s belief is theologically correct or widely shared. The question is whether the belief is sincerely held. Courts have found that unusual or non-mainstream beliefs still qualify.
You can ask clarifying questions to understand the nature of the request. You cannot interrogate the sincerity of the belief or require the employee to provide religious documentation in most cases.
What “Reasonable Accommodation” Looks Like in Practice
Common religious accommodations include:
• Schedule adjustments or shift swaps to avoid working on a religious day of rest
• Flexible start and end times to allow for religious observances
• Permission to wear religious attire (head coverings, religious jewelry, etc.)
• Time off for religious holidays not covered by the standard holiday schedule
• A private space for prayer during the workday
Not all of these will be feasible in every role or business. The analysis is specific to the accommodation requested and the nature of the business.
The Undue Hardship Standard
You can decline an accommodation if it would impose an undue hardship on the business. As of the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Groff v. DeJoy, the undue hardship standard for religious accommodations requires showing a substantial increased cost in relation to the conduct of the employer’s particular business.
This is a higher standard than the previous interpretation, which allowed denial based on more than minimal cost. The practical implication: the bar for denying a religious accommodation on hardship grounds is higher than it used to be. Inconvenience alone is not enough. Document your hardship analysis carefully if you deny a request. A great resource to help determine potential accommodations is the DOL’s Job Accommodation Network (JAN).
If You Deny the Accommodation
If you determine that an accommodation would impose an undue hardship, document your analysis in detail. Explore whether an alternative accommodation different from what the employee requested but still addressing the religious need might be feasible. Communicate your decision clearly and explain the basis.
A denial without engagement, documentation, or consideration of alternatives is the fastest path to a Title VII claim. For guidance on how to respond when an accommodation request escalates to a formal complaint, see Employee Filed a Harassment Complaint: What Do I Do?.
No Retaliation
You cannot take adverse action against an employee for requesting a religious accommodation. Even if you deny the request, the denial must be based on legitimate business hardship, not on frustration with the request or with the employee for making it.
Get an Anti-Harassment & Anti-Discrimination Policy Template
Our policy template covers all protected classes under Title VII (including religion) with reporting procedures and accommodation guidance built in.
→ Anti-Harassment & Anti-Discrimination Policy Template — $35 | pragmatichrgroup.com
Editable Word document + PDF. Instant download. Created by a SHRM-SCP certified HR professional.
Questions about this or other HR topics? Visit pragmatichrgroup.com for more resources.
